Here's what came back to me.
My granddaughter Mia, who's 8, started reading them to her little brothers.
She sent me a video. Her, on the floor, two little boys leaning on her, hanging on every word.
My son's 3-year-old calls them "Grandma's Jesus books." He won't let anybody else's books on that shelf.
And my daughter-in-law, the one with the laundry basket, sent me a text in April.
"The kids still ask for your books every night. Thank you for not sending more toys. I mean that."
April. The toys from December were long gone. The books were still being read.
This Christmas I'm not buying the loudest thing on the shelf.
Every one of my 7 grandkids is getting a book about Jesus from Grandma.
This Christmas every house gets Series 2, the next 11 books.
They'll get one toy each too. I'm not a monster.
But I know which gift will still be in the house at Easter.
Over 75,000 copies sold. I understand why now.
If you're a grandma with a long list and a short budget, look at that list.
Every toy on it will be broken or forgotten by New Year's.
Give them the one gift they'll ask you to read again.
P.S. I kept the headless doll. It sits on my sewing table. Every time I'm tempted by a toy aisle, I look at her.
Dramatization based on customer experiences. Individual results vary.